The Observer, 8 January 1995, by Kate Kellaway. Theatre homesickness and home truths. ----------------------------------------------------------- In Matthew Francis's honourable adaptation of "A Tale of Two Cities" (Greenwich Theatre) Dickens himself must take most credit. I was especially arrested by the passage where a city at night is described and we are asked to imagine that within each lit room there is a secret, and within every heart another. The lines ring out magically like Dickens's imaginative manifesto: given the chance, Dickens would, you feel, have energetically written his way into every room and heart. The actors serve Dickens well. The great pleasure of the evening is Timothy Walker's performance as Sydney Carton who fails in love but triumphs in death. He glitters with a self-hate that will later become a fevered, passionate selflessness. He looks as if he has dipped his fringe in sweat and rolled his frockcoat in dust. But he makes a sexy blackmailer, pouring brandies down his throat like repeated threats. Charles Darnay (Alexis Denisof) sounds and even looks unnervingly like a younger version of Tony Blair, full of noble ideas but never quite as interesting as you would wish him. Dr Manette (Julian Forsyth) resembles a Blakean prophet with long, waxy hair, while his daughter Lucie (Eleanor Tremain) is the perfect Dickensian heroine. A fearfully pale little flower, she demonstrates gracefully the advantages of being able to faint neatly in moments of crisis. She has a translucent forwardness and as a witness, simply by speaking the truth in Darnay's defence, sounds as though she were singing the sweetest love song. Miss Pross (Susan Porrett) is a comic triumph. Pross disapproves of most things including French cooking (she complains of having to 'make eggs do their business in a foreign pastry') and imagination. She'd disapprove of this show. "Leave Taking" is in rep at the Cottesloe, Royal National Theatre, London SE1 (071-928 2252) to 14 Jan, then tours the UK to 25 March; "A Tale of Two Cities" Greenwich Theatre, London SE10 (071-928 2252) to 4 Feb; "Quelques Fleurs" Old Red Lion, London EC1, (071-837 7816) to 28 Jan ----------------------------------------------------------- Bentley's Bedlam http://www.BetsyDa.com/bedlam.html This website is for information and entertainment purposes only and is not intended to infringe on copyrights held by others.